Skip to content

apiops init: generate a Copilot prompt file to audit artifacts against APIM best practices #202

Description

@EMaher

Problem or use case

After apiops extract, users have no guided way to check their extracted APIM artifacts against APIM best practices. The audit should look for anti-patterns (e.g. named values holding secrets that aren''t marked secret) that otherwise go unnoticed. We want a low-friction, Copilot-assisted audit that also offers to fix the issues it finds.

Proposed solution

Have apiops init generate an additional Copilot prompt file — e.g. .github/prompts/apiops-check-best-practices.prompt.md — following the same generation pattern as the existing identity-setup prompt (src/templates/copilot/identity-setup-prompt.ts, written in src/services/init-service.ts). When opened with GitHub Copilot, the prompt guides the user through auditing the artifacts in the repo against a focused set of APIM best practices.

Scope — only things apiops-cli tracks

Keep the checks centered on apiops-managed artifacts (policies, named values, backends, diagnostics/loggers, subscriptions, products). Explicitly out of scope: infra/SKU/networking/scale guidance from the WAF doc that doesn''t map to apiops artifacts.

Checks (initial set)

  1. Hardcoded secrets in policy.xml (headline check) — detect literal secrets in policy XML (set-header auth/keys, set-query-parameter code/sig, authentication-basic password, validate-jwt keys, connection-string fragments).
  2. Named values holding secrets that aren''t marked secret: true or aren''t Key Vault–backed → flag and offer to mark/migrate.
  3. Backend URLs / keys inlined in policies instead of using named values/backends → suggest parameterizing.

(Start with check #1; #2#3 can follow.)

Reference

APIM best-practice guidance: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/well-architected/service-guides/azure-api-management — used as a source, but the prompt should distill only the artifact-level items above rather than the full large-deployment guidance.

Affected command

apiops init (generates the prompt file); the prompt itself assists with apiops extract output.

Implementation notes

  • New template under src/templates/copilot/ (e.g. best-practices-prompt.ts) + embedded markdown, mirroring identity-setup-prompt.ts.
  • Write the file in init-service.ts alongside the identity prompt (conflict-check + add to generatedFiles.configs), and mention it in the init-command.ts next-steps output.
  • Relates to Secrets hardcoded in policy XML are not redacted on extract #198 (the CLI-side redact-and-warn for the same class of issue; this prompt is the interactive remediation counterpart).

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions